which combination of positions is better and why ?

hello Guys ;)

how do You rank players ?

based on positions in tactical drawings

or

based on role, style, influence on team ?

so my question is:

which combination of positions is better and why ?

A:

B2B , PM, TQ, SS, ST

or

B:

CM , AM, SS, ST


in other words:
is better to divide CM in to two groups: B2B and PM ?
than Zidane Iniesta are more PM than AM

if we take only CM position, we have players like Lampard or Gerrard, who are differnet to Xavi or Pirlo and Zidane or Iniesta aren't fits here

is better to divide AM in to two groups: TQ and some SS ?
than Rivaldo or Ronaldinho are more TQ than SS

some sources says that Zidane and Ronaldinho are both AM but Dinho played higher

but when we put Ronaldinho to SS, he wasn't as much goalscorer as other SS

CR is for some WF, but in Real he is mainly ST, he fits better to ST than SS

Raul is another example, he never was as creative force as Messi, Totti Bergkamp but he is take it as SS
isn't he more fit to ST ?

what about this combination ?

B2B - lampard, gerrard, ballack, seedorf, toure, vidal, etc
PM - zidane, xavi, pirlo, iniesta, scholes, modric, guardiola, etc
SS&TQ - messi, ronaldinho, rivaldo, bergkamp, totti, d.piero, rooney, etc
ST - R9, CR, henry, raul, ibra, eto'o, suarez, sheva, aguero, etc

but then where f.e. neymar or mueller fits better ?

which combination of positions is better and why ?